Private Assets, Listed Benchmarks: Why Canada's Pension Funds Are Being Judged by the Wrong Yardstick
Canada's largest pension plans all underperformed their benchmarks in the year to March 2026 — CPP Investments by 5.4 percentage points. The cause isn't poor private equity execution: it's a benchmarking convention, with eight of the country's largest plans measuring the same asset class against eight different, mostly listed, standards. Using privateMetrics® and the private2000® index, this paper shows private equity returned a market-wide 6.1% in calendar 2025 — measured against a genuine private-market benchmark, the plans' results look unremarkable rather than alarming — and argues for asset-class benchmarks that capture the market a fund is actually invested in.